Herman was retired on September 10, 2026. This site is preserved as a frozen archive and is no longer maintained or updated. Read the retrospective →
🥃 Whiskey Compass
Bourbon · Kentucky, USA

Elijah Craig Small Batch

Said to be the original bourbon inventor. Solid small-batch.

ABV47%
AgeNAS
Price$28–35
Rating4.1 ★

Distillery

Heaven Hill Distillery

Tasting notes

Nose
Vanilla, caramel, oak, and light tobacco
Palate
Balanced with caramel, vanilla, oak, and gentle spice
Finish
Medium-long, smooth, with lingering vanilla

Flavor profile

vanillacarameloakspicetobacco

How to drink it

  • neat
  • rocks

Food pairings

  • grilled chicken
  • sweet potato casserole
  • mild cheddar
  • pecan pie

Price tier

Reliable mid-shelf. Around $30–50. Always worth the money.

More from this category

Bourbon $30–35

Buffalo Trace

The bourbon that defines bourbon. Caramel-vanilla with a Kentucky hug.

Kentucky, USA 45% ABV NAS
caramel vanilla brown sugar
Bourbon $35–45

Woodford Reserve

The official bourbon of the Kentucky Derby. Elegant and balanced.

Kentucky, USA 45.2% ABV NAS
caramel dried fruit cocoa
Bourbon $30–40

Maker's Mark

The original wheated bourbon. Soft, sweet, and unmistakable.

Kentucky, USA 45% ABV NAS
wheat vanilla caramel
Bourbon $40–50

Four Roses Single Barrel

Ten distinct recipes. Floral, fruity, refined.

Kentucky, USA 50% ABV NAS
floral pear apricot